The Fickle Test of Taste

Almost 25 years ago, Trevor Nunn and the Royal Shakespeare Company reintroduced the world to this title when he conflated the two parts of The Fair Maid of the West into a single play. I saw the swashbuckling epic in London, and it was such a memorably fun night at the theatre that it left a lasting impression on me.

As I looked hard at this play(s) for possible inclusion in an ASC season, I lumped Fair Maid into a group of other plays that have seen their fair share of conflation. The end of this exploration left me utterly un-enamored with the idea of taking separate plays and squishing them together. I now have no interest in conflating Shakespeare’s amazing history plays – we’re in the middle of doing all ten of them individually (check out 2 Henry IV in our 2010 Fall Season and 3 Henry VI in our 2011 Actors’ Renaissance Season) – or blending both parts of Christopher Marlowe’s powerful Tamburlaine the Great (we’ll be doing Part 1 in the 2011 Fall Season, but we haven’t announced that year of programming, so shhh!, don’t tell anyone). I believe each of these magnificent plays provides more entertainment when staged separately.

In addition to penning both parts of The Fair Maid of the West, Thomas Heywood wrote, co-wrote, or helped group-write more than two hundred plays. His prolific output of popular entertainments, most of which have not survived the fickle test of taste over time, has caused some modern critics to call him “a hack.” Thankfully, Mr. Nunn thought better of him:

So why is Heywood worth our consideration today? Not only because of his
whirling narratives and demanding dramaturgy, and not only because he was
an entirely accessible, popular entertainer…but because in his adventure stories,
he conveys a disarming innocence, an uncomplicated childlike directness…Bess
is a heroine, like Indiana Jones is a hero, unambiguous and admirable.

But, (and this “but” is important), Mr. Nunn evidently didn’t think enough of Heywood to give us either of the real Fair Maid plays; instead, he gave us his own conflation that jammed pieces of both plays together in a way I now find completely unsatisfying. He cut small bits and great swaths from two plays that were written decades apart. He rearranged the order of many plot points and created a single production which was simply too much of a good
thing (he also left too many good lines/moments on the cutting room floor). I now believe that Part 1 is simply too wonderful on its own to squish it together with Part 2.

As well as staging great productions of Shakespeare’s plays, one of our other goals at the ASC is to rediscover early-modern gems by other playwrights and share them with our audiences in our Bring ‘Em Back Alive Staged-Reading Series and in fully-mounted productions. Shakespeare never really tried his hand at writing a romantic adventure quite in the vein of Fair Maid. Maybe Pericles or Cymbeline, (both written near the end of Shakespeare’s career, around 1607-10) could be considered cousins, but Heywood’s Fair Maid has more of what we would call a “summer blockbuster,” pop appeal than either of these Shakespeare plays (which would be more at home at the Sundance Festival for independent films rather than at your local mall’s multi-plex). Shakespeare’s Rosalind in As You Like It is probably the only female character put in charge of one of his plays in a way that compares
to Heywood’s cross-dressing fair maid, Bess Bridges; and Bess bests Roz in some ways because she gets to beat up Roughman, wield a sword, and command a pirate ship!

Fair Maid, Part 1 is a kind of fantastic fun that you don’t want to miss and that you’ll want to share with others.

Jim Warren
Artistic Director and Co-founder

< Back